Ballpark Vote-Off Game

[Yankee Legend]

Fans of the MLB Team, All-Star Vote-Off Game, and the Hall-of-fame Vote-Off Game!!!

Here is the much anticipated follow-up to the original success that saw the Washington Nationals, Vladimir Guerrero, and then Walter Johnson crowned as champion after 3 months of play.

The rules for this version will be the same, with a couple of changes

Rules (special thanks to otis89!!):

Vote + for one ballpark and - for another ballpark. Example: If you vote + for Polo Grounds, it goes up 1 point, and if you vote - for Ebbets Field, it goes down 1 point.

Once a ballpark reaches 0 points, they are eliminated.

Each ballpark will start with 5 points

First ballpark to 100 WINS!!

You may vote only ONCE a day.

Please copy the list from the last post in this thread to avoid any confusion.

REMEMBER TO POST THE UPDATED LIST WHEN YOU VOTE!!

I treid to make sure that as many teams' ballparks are represented.

Also, there are 2 more rules:

1. In every new post you must first type from (and whomever you copied the list from) as well as the post # of where you got the list.

2. If you feel a new stadium should be added, then you must state the name of the stadium as well as the name of a stadium already on the list of which 5 points will be taken from. Then, 4 other participants must agree and the new stadium will be included in the next list.

Enjoy!!

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 5
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 5
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 5
Milwaukee County Stadium 5
Polo Grounds 5
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 5
Tiger Stadium 5
Veterans Stadium 5
Wrigley Field 5
Yankee Stadium 5

[Yankee Legend]

k i guess ill start

Polo Grounds +
Astrodome -

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 5
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 5
Milwaukee County Stadium 5
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 5
Tiger Stadium 5
Veterans Stadium 5
Wrigley Field 5
Yankee Stadium 5

+ Wrigley Field
- Kingdome

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 5
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 5
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 5
Tiger Stadium 5
Veterans Stadium 5
Wrigley Field 6
Yankee Stadium 5

[ballparks]

Fenway+
Olympic Atrocity-

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 6+
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 5
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 4-
Tiger Stadium 5
Veterans Stadium 5
Wrigley Field 6
Yankee Stadium 5

I STRONGLY encourage people to break ranks with their 'team' affiliations for this game to make it most fun. I for one, as a Cardinals fan, would be considered blasphemous to be voting for Fenway Park. Voting for a park should NOT necessarily be like voting on team lines.
Thanks for starting the thread Legend!

[jrh31584]

Can I add some parks that were not on the original list, such as Turner Field, Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium, RFK Stadium, Citizens Bank Park, Riverfront Stadium, Great American Ballpark, PNC Park, Three Rivers Stadium, Minute Maid Park, Miller Park, Dodger Stadium, PETCO Park, AT&T Park, Camden Yards, Memorial Stadium, Exhibition Stadium, Tropicana Field, U.S. Cellular Field, Jacobs Field, League Park, Metropolitan Stadium, the Metrodome, Comerica Park, McAffee Coliseum, Municipal Stadium, Safeco Field, and Arlington Stadium?

[egautographs]

Kingdome+
Coors Field-

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 4
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 6
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 5
Milwaukee County Stadium 5
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 4
Tiger Stadium 5
Veterans Stadium 5
Wrigley Field 6
Yankee Stadium 5

Fenway Park +
Veterans Stadium -

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 5
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 4
Tiger Stadium 5
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 6
Yankee Stadium 5

[The Dude]

County Stadium +1
Olympique -1

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 3
Tiger Stadium 5
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 6
Yankee Stadium 5

[Yankee Legend]

Originally Posted by jrh31584

Can I add some parks that were not on the original list, such as Turner Field, Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium, RFK Stadium, Citizens Bank Park, Riverfront Stadium, Great American Ballpark, PNC Park, Three Rivers Stadium, Minute Maid Park, Miller Park, Dodger Stadium, PETCO Park, AT&T Park, Camden Yards, Memorial Stadium, Exhibition Stadium, Tropicana Field, U.S. Cellular Field, Jacobs Field, League Park, Metropolitan Stadium, the Metrodome, Comerica Park, McAffee Coliseum, Municipal Stadium, Safeco Field, and Arlington Stadium?

Believe me i examined many ballparks and i tried to limit to only 30. Also many of those parks would most likely be voted off anyway. I just chose the ones that are most popular and have longer tenures.

[RottenGazebo]

Tiger Stadium +1
Wrigley Field -1

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 5
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 3
Tiger Stadium 6
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 5
Yankee Stadium 5

[Dravecky43]

Candlestick Park -
Polo Grounds +

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 4
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 5
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 3
Tiger Stadium 6
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 5
Yankee Stadium 5

[catcher24]

Coors +
Olympic Stadium -

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 4
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 6
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 5
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 2
Tiger Stadium 6
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 5
Yankee Stadium 5
__________________

[Sean O]

Ebbets Field +
Candlestick Park-

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 3
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 6
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 6
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 2
Tiger Stadium 6
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 5
Yankee Stadium 5
________________

[RottenGazebo]

Hey, wait, aren't we supposed to vote only once? Everyone is posting two parks at a time.

[538280]

Stade Olympique +
Wrigley Field -

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 3
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 6
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 6
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 3
Tiger Stadium 6
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 4
Yankee Stadium 5

[Transplanted Fan]

+1 Wrigley Field
-1 Shea Stadium

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 3
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 5
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 6
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 6
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 4
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 3
Tiger Stadium 6
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 5
Yankee Stadium 5

[BoofBonser26]

Tiger Stadium +
Mistake on the Lake -

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 3
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 4
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 6
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 6
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 3
Tiger Stadium 7
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 4
Yankee Stadium 5

[steveox]

Memorial Stadium +
Candlestick Park -


Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 2
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 4
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 6
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 6
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Memorial Stadium 6
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 3
Tiger Stadium 7
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 4
Yankee Stadium 5
__________________

[Jake83]

Originally Posted by Yankee Legend

Believe me i examined many ballparks and i tried to limit to only 30. Also many of those parks would most likely be voted off anyway. I just chose the ones that are most popular and have longer tenures.

If that was tue then why isn;t Dodger Staduim on the list. It is a shame you left the 4th oldest ballpark in baseball and that has lead the league in attendance more times than not. If we can get 5 votes to replace Dodger Staduim to replace another staduim??? You even have 2 Gnat ballparks.
Mine is the first to place Dodger Staduim on the list instead of Angel Staduim

[Yankee Legend]

First of all, angels stadium is not a bad ballpark. The big "A" with the halo is very creative. The only reason you want it replaced is because your a dodgers fan and you hate the angels because they have Los Angeles in their name.

Also, if I was to replace a ballpark, believe me, i could name 3 or 4 ballparks to other than dodgers stadium to do it.

Look I couldn't put EVERYONE'S favorite ballparks on it. Everyone else seems to fine with the list.

[Elvis]

Originally Posted by Yankee Legend

First of all, angels stadium is not a bad ballpark. The big "A" with the halo is very creative. The only reason you want it replaced is because your a dodgers fan and you hate the angels because they have Los Angeles in their name.

Also, if I was to replace a ballpark, believe me, i could name 3 or 4 ballparks to other than dodgers stadium to do it.

Look I couldn't put EVERYONE'S favorite ballparks on it. Everyone else seems to fine with the list.

1. It's Angel Stadium and Dodger Stadium - no "s"
2. That "Big A" doesn't even have anything to do with that stadium anymore. It's like a quarter of a mile away from the stadium and is just used as an electric bilboard.
3. Dodger Stadium is a historic ballpark, having hosted 8 world series, the Pope, The Beatles and many, many other memorable moments - not easily replacable.
4. You can't expect us not to complain a little, seeing as virtually every other city is represented on your list, except Los Angeles, and maybe Seattle.

[Jake83]

Originally Posted by Yankee Legend

First of all, angels stadium is not a bad ballpark. The big "A" with the halo is very creative. The only reason you want it replaced is because your a dodgers fan and you hate the angels because they have Los Angeles in their name.

Also, if I was to replace a ballpark, believe me, i could name 3 or 4 ballparks to other than dodgers stadium to do it.

Look I couldn't put EVERYONE'S favorite ballparks on it. Everyone else seems to fine with the list.

Why did you leave Dodger Staduim off in the first place. Explain that

[Gagne#3 8]

If based on tradition and pouplarity Dodger Staduim should be on the list but I guess you have an Anti-Dodger bias. We haven't beaten the Yankees for awhile so you shouldn't dislike the Dodgers right now

[catcher24]

Coors +
Olympic -

Actually, Seattle is represented - Kingdome. Giants here twice - Polo and The Stick. I agree Dodger Stadium should be here, but I didn't do the list. If I had, it would also contain Jacobs Field and, IMHO, the best park in the game today, PNC Park.

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 2
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 4
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 7
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 6
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Memorial Stadium 6
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 7
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 2
Tiger Stadium 7
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 4
Yankee Stadium 5

[bigworm_122]

Yankee Stadium +
Polo Grounds -

Angels Stadium 5
Astrodome 4
Ballpark in Arlington 5
Bank One Ballpark 5
Braves Field 5
Busch Stadium 5
Candlestick Park 2
Cleveland Municipal Stadium 4
Comiskey Park 5
Coors Field 7
Crosley Field 5
Ebbets Field 6
Fenway Park 7
Forbes Field 5
Griffith Stadium 5
Jack Murphy Stadium 5
Kingdome 4
Memorial Stadium 6
Milwaukee County Stadium 6
Polo Grounds 6
Pro Player Stadium 5
Royals Stadium 5
Shibe Park 5
Shea Stadium 5
Skydome 5
Sportsman's Park 5
Stade Olympique 2
Tiger Stadium 7
Veterans Stadium 4
Wrigley Field 4
Yankee Stadium 6