Best hitter's park?

Overall, (foul area, gaps, climate etc.) what MLB park do yall think favors hitters the most?

Here is the Top 10 parks in the leauge favoring hitters in the area of Runs using ESPN's "Park Factor" stat. This stat isn't very dependable because it is based on the performances of hitters on that team, not anybody else.
1.Fenway Park (Red Sox)
2 Kauffman Stadium (Royals)
3 Coors Field (Rockies)
4 Ameriquest Field (Rangers)
5 Bank One Ballpark (Diamondbacks)
6 Rogers Centre (Blue Jays)
7 Metrodome (Twins)
8 Minute Maid Park (Astros)
9 Wrigley Field (Cubs)
10 Miller Park (Brewers)
11 Citizens Bank Park (Phillies)
12 Tropicana Field (Devil Rays)
13 Great American (Reds)
14 PNC Park (Pirates)
15 Shea Stadium (Mets)

Its Coors field and then Fenway. Fenway is just a ridicilous ball park. If another team today tried to build something that looked like Fenway, they'd get shot down easily.

[PopTop]

Over the last three seasons or so, I'd be willing to bet that the old Ballpark in Arlington has surrendered the most homers and ranks in the top 2-3 in total runs.

[sschirmer]

Wow, I can't believe Great American is that far down. It seems to play like a bandbox. Coors isn't so much the park, but rather the location it's in.

[Sound2TheBay™]

Camden Yards.

[Ravenlord]

Originally Posted by sschirmer

Wow, I can't believe Great American is that far down. It seems to play like a bandbox. Coors isn't so much the park, but rather the location it's in.

Great America actually plays as a slight pitcher's park. it allows an incredible ammount of homers, but that's quite possibly just the Reds pitchers. as long as you're not a flyball pitcher, you'll do well at GAB (assuming you don't suck to begin with).

[Chisox73]

Originally Posted by PopTop

Over the last three seasons or so, I'd be willing to bet that the old Ballpark in Arlington has surrendered the most homers and ranks in the top 2-3 in total runs.

Actually,that honor goes to of all places,US Cellular Field in Chicago as far as home runs are concerned.

[rainout]

Originally Posted by Ravenlord

Great America actually plays as a slight pitcher's park. it allows an incredible ammount of homers, but that's quite possibly just the Reds pitchers. as long as you're not a flyball pitcher, you'll do well at GAB (assuming you don't suck to begin with).

Has anyone with tthe Reds ever attempted to explain the acquisition of Eric Milton? What a dumb move.

[Ravenlord]

Originally Posted by rainout

Has anyone with tthe Reds ever attempted to explain the acquisition of Eric Milton? What a dumb move.

"he knows how to win" and "the Yankees wanted him" and "we think he can become a sinkerball pitcher."

on the plus side, the Reds did fire the guy who said the third thing.

[sschirmer]

Originally Posted by Ravenlord

Great America actually plays as a slight pitcher's park. it allows an incredible ammount of homers, but that's quite possibly just the Reds pitchers. as long as you're not a flyball pitcher, you'll do well at GAB (assuming you don't suck to begin with).

Let me guess, Dan O'Brien is your brother-in-law? His whole arguement in signing Milton is that GABP plays as a neutral park. Apparently, he's never been to a game there.

[ArealBASEBALLfan]

How can Fenway even be on the list. do you know how hard it would be to hit it over the green monster?

[sschirmer]

Originally Posted by ArealBASEBALLfan

How can Fenway even be on the list. do you know how hard it would be to hit it over the green monster?

Ah yeah, not very.

[Joltin' Joe]

I don't understand how anyone can vote for any park that is not called COORS FIELD

[sschirmer]

Originally Posted by Joltin' Joe

I don't understand how anyone can vote for any park that is not called COORS FIELD

My only reason for that is I that I believe the city it is located in, and not the park itself, is responsible for the offensive numbers there. If we are talking "hitters city", then yes, I would vote for Denver.

[Ravenlord]

Originally Posted by sschirmer

Let me guess, Dan O'Brien is your brother-in-law? His whole arguement in signing Milton is that GABP plays as a neutral park. Apparently, he's never been to a game there.

if you throw groundballs, you get the benefit of the rain forest that the Reds call an infield. look at the splits the last 3 years on the excessive FB pitchers and the excessive GB pitchers. unless you're a crappy GB pitcher to begin with (Anderson, Graves) you have better numbers at GAB.

and O'Brien's logic is as above..."he knows how to win," "the Yankees wanted him," and Gullett told everybody he could turn Milton into a sinkerballer.

and if Dan O'Brien was an in-law of of mine, i would have killed him and taken his place by now.

[sschirmer]

Originally Posted by Ravenlord

if you throw groundballs, you get the benefit of the rain forest that the Reds call an infield. look at the splits the last 3 years on the excessive FB pitchers and the excessive GB pitchers. unless you're a crappy GB pitcher to begin with (Anderson, Graves) you have better numbers at GAB.

and O'Brien's logic is as above..."he knows how to win," "the Yankees wanted him," and Gullett told everybody he could turn Milton into a sinkerballer.

and if Dan O'Brien was an in-law of of mine, i would have killed him and taken his place by now.

LOL! I'm glad you took the joke! Milty is a flyball pitcher, and GABP is where flyball pitchers go to die!

[csh19792001]

Originally Posted by Ravenlord

Great America actually plays as a slight pitcher's park. it allows an incredible ammount of homers, but that's quite possibly just the Reds pitchers. as long as you're not a flyball pitcher, you'll do well at GAB (assuming you don't suck to begin with).

You're correct, as odd as it seems.

What's the park factor been for the place that has been deemed "The Great American Bandbox"?

It's was 3rd among the 30 stadiums in home run factor in 2005, but only 13th in terms in overall park factor.

In 2004, 13th in terms of HRS, 23rd in park factor.

2003: 5th, 17th.

[csh19792001]

Originally Posted by rainout

Has anyone with tthe Reds ever attempted to explain the acquisition of Eric Milton? What a dumb move.

Has to be the worst season put together by anyone with a full season worth of starts (34) in my entire lifetime. Truly pathetic campaign.

[efin98]

Originally Posted by ArealBASEBALLfan

How can Fenway even be on the list. do you know how hard it would be to hit it over the green monster?

Even if it's 37' tall it's still only 310' from home plate. Not to mention right field is only 302' with a short wall.

There's a reason Manny Ramirez and David Ortiz have over 40 homers and 140 RBIs each this year

[efin98]

Originally Posted by sschirmer

My only reason for that is I that I believe the city it is located in, and not the park itself, is responsible for the offensive numbers there. If we are talking "hitters city", then yes, I would vote for Denver.

The dimensions would be "a pitcher's park" at most, neutral in the least in any other city. It's the thin air that sends the balls flying, that and the bad pitching

[Joltin' Joe]

Originally Posted by efin98

The dimensions would be "a pitcher's park" at most, neutral in the least in any other city. It's the thin air that sends the balls flying, that and the bad pitching

The big park also accounts for a ton of balls dropping in between the outfielders for a single, double, & triples. And because of the thin air, despite the huge dimensions, the balls fly out of the park as well.

The third element is that in the thin air, breaking balls do not break, curves don't curve, sinkers don't sink, splitters don't split(?), etc etc etc.....

[SHOELESSJOE3]

Originally Posted by Joltin' Joe

The big park also accounts for a ton of balls dropping in between the outfielders for a single, double, & triples. And because of the thin air, despite the huge dimensions, the balls fly out of the park as well.

The third element is that in the thin air, breaking balls do not break, curves don't curve, sinkers don't sink, splitters don't split(?), etc etc etc.....

That says it all Joe, I posted the same, almost exactly the same words earlier.

On your first paragraph. The fact that outfielders know that balls carry well there causes them to play deeper and as you state allows more balls to drop in front of the outfielders.

You touch on the breaking balls, breaking less at Coors, very important. I think we all know the difference in even fractions of an inch where the bat meets the ball, the difference between driving the ball or getting under it.

Coors has it all, if your the batter. I saw some where that a ball hit at Yankee Stadium 400 feet would travel 420 to 440 at Coors.

[Blackout]

best park: fenway

best weather atmosphere: coors

[Blackout]

Originally Posted by ArealBASEBALLfan

How can Fenway even be on the list. do you know how hard it would be to hit it over the green monster?

because what would be a routine fly ball at most stadiums can EASILY turn into either a double or a home run at fenway (or if your a fast runner you can squeeze a triple off Manny)