PDA

View Full Version : What do you consider a card of your team?


dabigyankeeman
09-04-2009, 02:31 PM
I collect Yankees, old and new, and lately I have added jersey or bat memorabilia cards as a sub-collection.

I have a couple of cards where the player is shown in another team's uniform, and the the jersey is obviously from the other team, yet the card says YANKEES as the team.

The cards are a Pudge Rodgriquez and a Johnny Damon, obviously produced right after they moved to the Yankees.

On the Pudge card, it has the Yankee logo on the front, which really makes it look like a Yankee card, on the Damon card it just says Yankees on the front, although there is a Yankee logo on the back.

What I did was put the Pudge card into my Yankees collection for two reasons, one is that the logo stands out and makes you think of the Yankees, and two is that fact that since he is gone from the team already, there wont be any memorabilia cards produced of him wearing a Yankee uniform (unless its out there and I dont know about it).

I did NOT put the Damon card into my Yankees collection for a few reasons. Without the logo, and just a small "Yankees" on it, it just doesnt strike you as being a Yankee card when you look at it, also I already have a true Yankees Damon jersey card with his photo in a Yankee uniform and two swatches from a Yankee jersey, and finally, the picture on the card is of him in a hated Red Sox jersey, and looking at the card, it looks like a Red Sox card. I pulled this one out of a pack, I bought the Pudge card.

I have this problem with regular, non memorabilia cards too, but i virtually always wind up putting them in my Yankee collection if it says Yankees as the team.

What do you guys do if you are team collectors or sort by team?

Extra Innings
09-04-2009, 02:54 PM
I have a couple of cards where the player is shown in another team's uniform, and the the jersey is obviously from the other team, yet the card says YANKEES as the team.

What do you guys do if you are team collectors or sort by team?

I just sort them with current team they play for. You run into these things with Series 1 Topps and UD. I don't sort my G/U cards by team since I don't have many, but I know what your talking about. I've got an SPx Andruw Jones relic card that pictures him as a Brave and the patch is from a Braves jersey, but in small print it says 'Dodgers'.

ItsOnlyGil
09-04-2009, 04:08 PM
My practise is to follow what it says on the card independent of whether the uniform matches. It is ok with me if they produced the card after the team change, but before a new uniform photo was available for them.

However, what is not ok is when there is a player mismatch. By this I mean that the name on the card is for a player other than the one shown. In this case, the portrayal overrides the description, stats and other identifiers. A picture of Jeter on a card named Rodriguez is a Jeter card.

EricDavis
09-04-2009, 10:26 PM
I collect EVERY card of ANY player who has ever played for the Reds or had a minorleague card produced of him as a Red, before his ML debut (And I have to MiLB card to put him in the collection). So it's pretty extensive.

dabigyankeeman
09-05-2009, 05:59 AM
I collect EVERY card of ANY player who has ever played for the Reds or had a minorleague card produced of him as a Red, before his ML debut (And I have to MiLB card to put him in the collection). So it's pretty extensive.

Thats a great way to collect. I myself have considered starting some new albums called YANKEES CONNECTION, meaning cards of players now NOT on the Yankees but who once played for them or came up thru their minor league system. Enjoy your collection!

yankeesjetsfan
09-08-2009, 09:19 AM
I am a Yankees collector myself. I have well over 10,000 base, insert, gu and auto cards in my collection. My criteria is the card has to say Yankees on it. If the player is in a Yankees uniform, but says another team on it, then it wont make the collection. To me, that's a card for that teams set. Just my opinon.

Good luck with your collection. It's a fun hobby.

Mike

flyingdutchdude
09-11-2009, 10:01 PM
Yankee collectors should collect cards of the New York Highlanders too since they were the same franchise. Any 1910 era T206 card of a New York AL player is really a Highlander, and not a Yankee as that mascot was not used yet.

Collect what you like.

That problem you mention is not a new one. Cards have been made that way for many many years now. It was common in the early 1900s too, especially when the same photo was reused over and over for some players.

Here is an example below of a 1919 T213-3 card... One of the last (baseball) cigarette cards.