PDA

View Full Version : Nationals "prospect" lied about name & age


Zito75
02-19-2009, 10:23 AM
Wow... And you all throught steroid use is cheating...


VIERA, Fla. (AP)—A top baseball prospect from the Dominican Republic who received a $1.4 million signing bonus from the Washington Nationals lied about his age and name in what team president Stan Kasten called “an elaborate scheme.”

“I’m angry. I’m very angry. We’ve been defrauded,” Kasten said Wednesday. “And make no mistake: This wasn’t a college kid with a fake ID.”

“This was a deliberate, premeditated fraud” that involved bribes, along with falsified hospital and school records, Kasten said.

In July 2006, to much fanfare, the Nationals signed a 16-year-old shortstop named Esmailyn “Smiley” Gonzalez and held a news conference at which general manager Jim Bowden compared the player to Hall of Famer Ozzie Smith. Still known as Gonzalez, he wound up leading the rookie-level Gulf Coast League with a .343 batting average in 2008 and was honored as the league’s MVP.

But while the Nationals have been listing his date of birth as Sept. 21, 1989—which would make him 19 now—Kasten said Wednesday that a Major League Baseball investigation determined Gonzalez is actually Carlos David Alvarez Lugo, born in November 1985—meaning he is really 23.

“This is going to have serious repercussions,” said Kasten, who spoke to reporters after SI.com first reported on Gonzalez/Lugo. “I have people examining all possible avenues of recourse, with regards to any legal and financial concerns.”

While Kasten said there were “a number of people involved” in the hoax, he would not say whether anyone employed by the Nationals is suspected of playing a role.

“I’m not going to say anything right now while the investigation continues,” Kasten said.

As for the player, Kasten said: “This is a big difference between being a 16-year-old and a 20-year-old. Do I know what his future holds as a baseball player? I don’t. I would say clearly he remains a prospect—but I would say a very different kind of prospect—today. I’m not prepared to say what is going to happen in his career just yet.”

He would be scheduled to report to Nationals minor league camp March 13.

“I didn’t know anything about this. I never had any indication that he was anyone other than Esmailyn. I feel bad for the organization, and I feel bad for the kid,” the player’s agent, Stanley King, said in a telephone interview.

King, who also represents Nationals starting shortstop Cristian Guzman, said he hadn’t spoken to Gonzalez since the story broke.

“This thing is unraveling like a Greek tragedy,” King said.

Jose Rijo, a special assistant to Bowden, was credited with spotting Gonzalez in the Dominican about two years before the Nationals signed him.

“I loved him from the beginning,” Rijo said Wednesday in the home clubhouse at Space Coast Stadium, where the Nationals hold spring training.

AutographCollector
02-19-2009, 10:40 AM
Adding more to Zito's story:

In this July 2, 2006 file photo, Washington Nationals manager Frank Robinson, right, looks at Esmailyn Gonzalez, left, at a press conference to announce that the Nationals agreed to terms with the 16-year-old amateur free-agent shortstop from the Dominican Republic in Washington. The Nationals have been listing Gonzalez's date of birth as Sept. 21, 1989, which would make him 19 now. Team president Stan Kasten said Wednesday, Feb. 18, 2009 that a Major League Baseball investigation determined Gonzalez is actually Carlos David Alvarez Lugo, born in November 1985, meaning he is really 23.

Gary Dunaier
02-19-2009, 10:46 AM
Interesting story.

Has he appeared on any baseball cards?

Lafferty Daniel
02-19-2009, 10:54 AM
Glad I didn't draft him during my recent dynasty league MiLB draft. 23 is way too old for a guy that hasn't even played Low A.

AutographCollector
02-19-2009, 11:25 AM
Has he appeared on any baseball cards?

Not to my knowledge. But if he has... I haven't seen it.

spark240
02-19-2009, 11:54 AM
I would say clearly he remains a prospect

Are they seriously thinking he might continue his career with the Nationals? :disbelief:

Paulypal
02-19-2009, 12:10 PM
This is not uncommon at all. Soriano admitted to this a couple of years ago.

I play modified fast pitch softball on Long Island. I play with and agains quite few players that were born and played in the DR. A few of which that were drafted by MLB teams. One guy was 19 when he was contacted. They told him ok now your 16, and took care of the paperwork.

He never made it but this story is not uncommon at all.

spark240
02-19-2009, 12:15 PM
Sometimes the scouts who recommend the player to their organization are the ones who suggest the deceit. This instance sounds like a more elaborate plot than most.

sturg1dj
02-19-2009, 12:15 PM
the schools in the Latin American countries take say 100 players and one ends up going to the states. They are in these schools during the years that they could get job training or an education. If they are not sent to America they are dropped right back into their home towns with no job skills in areas that are already impoverished.

At the same time a 16 years old prospect is more likely to make it than an 18 year old prospect.

So, what would you do?

KevinWI
02-19-2009, 01:25 PM
His age shouldn't matter. He was the league's MVP last year and suddenly, they find out that he's older than they thought and he goes from being a valued prospect to what, a Crash Davis lifetime minor leaguer?

Lying is wrong, but I feel sorry for him. He's getting screwed by the sport.

Dalkowski110
02-19-2009, 03:44 PM
"Not to my knowledge. But if he has... I haven't seen it."

He has. 2008 Bowman Chrome. As Esmailyn Gonzalez. I also have some cards of "Jairo Garcia" before it was revealed he was really Santiago Casilla.

spark240
02-19-2009, 03:47 PM
His age shouldn't matter. He was the league's MVP last year and suddenly, they find out that he's older than they thought and he goes from being a valued prospect to what, a Crash Davis lifetime minor leaguer?

Lying is wrong, but I feel sorry for him. He's getting screwed by the sport.

Age is a huge factor in understanding the development of baseball skill.

Being the MVP in a low-level league at age X is not the same as doing it at age X+3.

blacksilverfan12
02-19-2009, 04:09 PM
Can't really blame him. I think most people would do the same to get out of the poverty-stricken areas of Latin America

kiluckzle
02-19-2009, 06:35 PM
Has anything that the Nats done in the past couple of years turned out well at all? They just can't seem to catch a break.

rockin500
02-19-2009, 07:13 PM
His age shouldn't matter. He was the league's MVP last year and suddenly, they find out that he's older than they thought and he goes from being a valued prospect to what, a Crash Davis lifetime minor leaguer?

Lying is wrong, but I feel sorry for him. He's getting screwed by the sport.
uh, yeah, 4 years is a big damned deal. when a player's athletic career can only last so long, to lose 4 years is pretty damned significant. Not to mention, doing something in rookie ball at 23 is much less impressive than doing it at 19.

Lafferty Daniel
02-19-2009, 07:41 PM
Has anything that the Nats done in the past couple of years turned out well at all? They just can't seem to catch a break.

We'll see after this season. Lastings Milledge looked very good during the second half last year. Elijah Dukes could break out this year. Jordan Zimmerman could step up this year. Detwiler and Marrero had step backs last season, but have the talent and opportunities in their system to succeed. I also like the power potential of Michael Burgess, and the future of Jack McGeary.