#1 pitcher in Marlins history

[OhioBoy]

Who is the greatest pitcher in franchise history?

[NJMetfan4life]

Here's the stats for all the pitchers.

http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/stats/historical/player_stats.jsp?teamPosCode=all&statType=2&timeFrame=3&Submit=Submit&c_id=fla&sitSplit=&timeSubFrame2=0&venueID=&baseballScope=FLO&timeSubFrame=0&&sortByStat=SO

[gman5431]

Before looking at the stats provided, i went with Beckett and after looking at the stats i feel good about my pick. Also, i considered the D Train. Where is Livan Hernandez? Seems like he should at least be on the list. Picked Beckett mostly due to his WS triumph over the Yanks. That put him ahead of D Train for me. See that he has third best ERA of the group and thats behind Brown who has just over half the games and Nen who is a reliever.

G Man

[KCGHOST]

I usually like Quality over Quantity but I also like home grown over imported. I'll take Beckett's five year's over Brown's two year.

[OhioBoy]

I'll take the D-train's 68-54 record over Beckett's 41-34 record

[nl1899fan]

I picked Willis-best of a weak bunch.

[soxfan34]

Josh Beckett is the best
Dontrelle Willis is number 2

[Extra Innings]

Basing it on Marlins history, I went with Dontrelle Willis. Beckett could have easily been my choice too, but looking back Willis will probably be better known as a Marlin.

[Inge15]

I'll take D-Train. So many complete games, so many.

[The Commissioner]

It's really difficult to make a choice. This is a ballclub with such a relatively short history and a tradition of fire sales. In the end, I had to go with Willis.

[Inge15]

I really don't think anyone could say anyone other than Dontrelle or Josh Beckett.

[1988_Night_Force_Falcon]

I went with Rob Nenn, he was pretty dominant during their first WS run. Beckett, D-Train and Brown really haven't stuck around to put up some definite easy-choice numbers for me one way or the other.

[KevinWI]

My vote above was merely for the lulz.

[redban]

Al Leiter should have at least been on the poll..

[JerseeJerry55]

Who is the greatest pitcher in franchise history?

As an outsider I looked at it objectively. I wanted to vote for Dontrelle, but I took Beckett reluctantly. Great pitcher, but I don't like his mound demeanor. Beckett seems like a punk at most times.

[Gravy Train]

Kevin Brown. Sure, he had a very brief Marlins career, but it's not like any of the other options were around for long, either. Amazing that a poll like this can be so uninspiring, considering this team has won two World Series. I guess firesales can do that, though.

[BravesFanForever]

Josh Johnson has been nothing short of amazing this year, maybe he should get some looking at? His career is still young though (especially with the injuries).

[TonyStarks]

The D-Train. He stayed healthy, won more games, threw more innings and kept a respectable ERA. Don't forget Dontrelle was a good hitter for a pitcher also.