New Generation Poll #2 (Read Message First)

[The Dude]

Round 1 Results:
1.Johan Santana: 45% (14 Votes)
-Jake Peavy: 19% (6 Votes)
-Brandon Webb: 16% (5 Votes)
-Roy Halladay: 10% (3 Votes)
-Roy Oswalt: 6% (2 Votes)
-Josh Beckett: 3% (1 Vote)

So here's the setup. The pitcher must be under the age of 32, and have at least 75 MLB starts. Poll is open 4 days

Vote for your new top choice ...



Player GS IP W L CG SHO K's ERA+ WHIP BI GI
Bedard, Erik 115 682 42 35 1 1 659 120 1.33 2 19
Buehrle, Mark 240 1,665 108 78 23 7 966 122 1.26 7 78
Beckett, Josh 171 1,048 80 54 4 2 993 116 1.22 4 41
Haren, Danny 128 824 53 45 5 0 642 114 1.23 3 44
Hernandez, Felix 80 516 32 27 4 2 462 112 1.30 0 21
Halladay, Roy 229 1,618 114 59 35 9 1,119 129 1.22 23 106
Grienke, Zack 77 499 24 36 3 0 353 105 1.33 0 14
Kazmir, Scott 98 574 35 30 1 1 622 122 1.39 5 16
Peavy, Jake 179 1,136 80 52 6 3 1,136 120 1.18 23 80
Oswalt, Roy 216 1,455 115 57 12 4 1,203 139 1.21 14 94
Sheets, Ben 196 1,269 77 74 14 2 1,080 114 1.19 6 52
Sabathia, C.C. 226 1,444 101 68 16 5 1,179 113 1.28 9 78
Webb, Brandon 170 1,136 72 55 12 7 917 145 1.23 20 77
Zambrano, Carlos 187 1,240 85 56 7 2 1,077 132 1.28 5 91


Bedard, Erik:
2002-2007: Balitmore Orioles
2008-: Seattle Mariners

Buehrle, Mark:
2000-: Chicago White Sox
-No-Hitter in 2006
-3 All-Star Appearances
-2 Playoff Appearances
-1 WS Ring

Beckett, Josh:
2001-2005: Florida Marlins
2006-: Boston Red Sox
-1 All-Star Appearance
-2 Playoff Appearances
-2 WS Rings
-1 Cy Young Award

Haren, Danny:
2002-2003: St. Louis Cardinals
2004-2007: Oakland Athletics
2008-: Arizona Diamondbacks
-1 All-Star Appearance
-2 Playoff Appearances
-1 WS Ring

Hernandez, Felix:
2005-:Seattle Mariners

Halladay, Roy:
1998-:Toronto Blue Jays
-4 All-Star Appearances
-1 Cy Young Award

Grienke, Zack:
2004-: Kansas City Royals

Kazmir, Scott:
2004-: Tampa Bay (Devil) Rays
-1 All-Star Appearance

Peavy, Jake:
2002-: San Diego Padres
-2 All-Star Appearances
-2 Playoff Appearances
-1 Cy Young Award

Oswalt, Roy:
2001-: Houston Astros
-1 Inning of No-Hitter in 2003
-3 All-Star Appearances
-2 Playoff Appearances

Sheets, Ben:
2000-: Milwaukee Brewers
-3 All-Star Appearances

Sabathia, C.C.:
2001-: Cleveland Indians
-3 All-Star Appearances
-2 Playoff Appearances


Webb, Brandon:
2002-: Arizona Diamondbacks
-2 All-Star Appearances
-1 Playoff Appearance
-ROY Award
-1 Cy Young Award

Zambrano, Carlos:
2001-: Chicago Cubs
-2 All-Star Appearances
-2 Playoff Appearances

[The Dude]

I expected Santana to win the first round ... but this one should be interesting. I think it'll come down to Halladay, Oswalt, and Webb...

[The Dude]

Poll Closes in a day, and I'm rather suprised by the showing ... seeing as how it's rather unclear who the no.2 is.