I had to get in the record book somehow.

[soberdennis]

What do the following pitchers have in common.
Willis Hudlin
Pat Jarvis
Stu Miller
Fred Scherman
Mike McCormick
Don Nottebart
Mike Cuellar
Don Robinson
Bud Black
Andy Ashby
Win Hawkins

[RuthMayBond]

They gave up 500th homers

[RuthMayBond]

What do the following pitchers have in common.
Willis Hudlin
Pat Jarvis
Stu Miller
Fred Scherman
Mike McCormick
Don Nottebart
Mike Cuellar
Don Robinson
Bud Black
Andy Ashby
Win HawkinsI think you need to add
Scott Sullivan
Terry Adams
David Elder
Matt Morris
Jamie Easterly
Juan Marichal
Johnny Hutchings
Felipe Lira
George Caster

[soberdennis]

I think you need to add
Scott Sullivan
Terry Adams
David Elder
Matt Morris
Jamie Easterly
Juan Marichal
Johnny Hutchings
Felipe Lira
George Caster
Thank you for completing the list. I did not claim my list was all inclusive. I listed the ones I could figure out by the boxscores.

[anjo25]

They gave up 500th homers

Robin Roberts is the only pitcher to give up 500+ HRs

[flea45]

500th homers...as in the hitter hit his 500th homer while they were pitching....not that the each gave up 500hr's.

[soberdennis]

Exactly. The answer was correct as has been explained. For example, Stu Miller gave up Mantle's 500th homer May 14, 1967.