PDA

View Full Version : 2007 picks


baseball=my life
09-22-2006, 11:05 AM
I hear that 2007 is going to be a great year to go to cooperstown for the induction ceremony. Many great ballplayers have retired in recent years. Who do you all think is being inducted in '07?

candy curveball cummings
09-22-2006, 11:25 AM
I hear that 2007 is going to be a great year to go to cooperstown for the induction ceremony. Many great ballplayers have retired in recent years. Who do you all think is being inducted in '07?

I only see two making it this year, and those guys are Ripken and Gwynn. McGwire is close, but I think he'll miss it this time.

Captain Cold Nose
09-25-2006, 05:25 AM
I'm planning on being there, seeing Gwynn and Ripken. McGwire has a solid chance, but I wouldn't be shocked if he's not there.
I'd love to see the VC do their jobs and elect somebody. I think Ron Santo has a legit chance.

candy curveball cummings
09-25-2006, 11:21 AM
I'd love to see the VC do their jobs and elect somebody. I think Ron Santo has a legit chance.

That would be awfully nice, wouldn't it?

538280
09-25-2006, 05:25 PM
Tony Fernandez will come on to the ballot this year. I expect him to be one and done, but he's a guy who should probably get more support than he does. I'm as skeptical of WARP3 as all of you are (consider we don't know how it's calculated, I generally don't look at it much), but he does very strong with that.

He was known as a very good to great fielding shortstop, had a very good BA in his best best years, learned to take a walk later on, and had pretty decent power from SS in a pretty long career. He held the single season record for hits by a shortstop for some time (213 in 1986) , if you like those sorts of records. I remember watching him play a bit towards the end of his career and I really liked him though, so maybe I'm being too subjective because I've never seen anyone but me bring him up here.

Captain Cold Nose
09-26-2006, 06:34 AM
Tony Fernandez will come on to the ballot this year. I expect him to be one and done, but he's a guy who should probably get more support than he does. I'm as skeptical of WARP3 as all of you are (consider we don't know how it's calculated, I generally don't look at it much), but he does very strong with that.

He was known as a very good to great fielding shortstop, had a very good BA in his best best years, learned to take a walk later on, and had pretty decent power from SS in a pretty long career. He held the single season record for hits by a shortstop for some time (213 in 1986) , if you like those sorts of records. I remember watching him play a bit towards the end of his career and I really liked him though, so maybe I'm being too subjective because I've never seen anyone but me bring him up here.
Fernandez was a bit of a journeyman, but in the context of his time he was considered right there with Ripken and Trammell for AS consideration. A very good player.
I remember when the Reds signed him, and had the intentions of moving him to second because Barry Larkin was firmly planted at short. Bret Boone made quite a spectacle of himself openly defying manager/tool Ray Knight and refusing to move to third at first. Boone's tirades and lack of hitting that year got him demoted for a short time. And the Reds writers treated him like he was a hero.
I'm glad Boone found himself when he returned to Seattle. But I got a very poor impression of Boone due to that. Fernandez only wanted to do his job, and the position switch didn't seem to bother him.