Missing

[janduscframe]

body parts. Match'em up..

a.kidney 1.Gene Bearden

b.part of his skull 2.Antonio Alfonseca

c. thumb 3. Bill Tuttle

d.arm 4.Carlos May

e.leg 5.Monty Stratton

f. part of his face 6.Mordecai Brown

g.part of his index finger 7. Trevor Hoffman

h.has spare parts 8.Pete Gray

[RuthMayBond]

body parts. Match'em up..

a.kidney 1.Gene Bearden

b.part of his skull 2.Antonio Alfonseca

c. thumb 3. Bill Tuttle

d.arm 4.Carlos May

e.leg 5.Monty Stratton

f. part of his face 6.Mordecai Brown

g.part of his index finger 7. Trevor Hoffman

h.has spare parts 8.Pete Gray
Antonio Alfonseca has spare toes
Pete Gray was missing an arm
Mordecai Brown, part of his index finger?

[janduscframe]

You're three for three.

[Bob Hannah]

Missing leg is Stratton.

Thumb is Carlos May.

[Honus Wagner]

Bill Tuttle died of oral cancer from chewing tobacco

[wamby]

Gene Bearden had a metal plate in his head (and a reconstruced leg) from war injuries sustained during the sinking of the USS Helena,

[Honus Wagner]

Gene Bearden had a metal plate in his head (and a reconstruced leg) from war injuries sustained during the sinking of the USS Helena,

then i guess, hoffman has only 1 kidney (???)
tuttle lost part of his face (jaw)
bearden lost part of his skull

[janduscframe]

You guys got it...

[flash143817]

Alfonseca has 6 fingers on each hand. I guess that is what the "spare parts" refers to.