Brewers' All-Time Starters (vote for 5)

[Hammerin Hank]

Who are the Brewers' all-time starting pitchers? VOTE FOR 5.

Ricky Bones (1992-96)
Chris Bosio (1986-92)
Mike Caldwell (1977-84)
Jim Colborn (1972-76)
Cal Eldred (1991-99)
Moose Haas (1976-85)
Teddy Higuera (1985-94)
Scott Karl (1995-99)
Skip Lockwood (1970-73)
Jaime Navarro (1989-94, 2000)
Ben Sheets (2001- )
Jim Slaton (1971-77, 79-83)
Lary Sorensen (1977-80)
Bill Travers (1974-80)
Bill Wegman (1985-95)

[Hammerin Hank]

Again to qualify, they needed to pitch at least four full seasons with the Brewers.

[Hammerin Hank]

My votes go to the following:
Mike Caldwell: 102-80, 3.74 ERA, 540 SO
Moose Haas: 91-79, 4.03 ERA, 800 SO
Teddy Higuera: 94-64, 3.61 ERA, 1081 SO
Ben Sheets: 57-65, 3.86 ERA, 869 SO
Jim Slaton: 117-121, 3.86 ERA, 929 SO

[The Dude]

I'm suprised Teddy Higuera is in a tie...people must not know how good he was.

Past the fact that he's that good, he's the only brewers pitcher not to have just a string of mediocre seasons with one or two great seasons thrown in there (Caldwell, Haas, Sheets)

[Hammerin Hank]

There's definitely no way why Sheets should be leading in votes. He's had two good seasons. I may have voted for him but he was my last pick, and it was rather close with about two other pitchers.