Top Ten Current Best Third baseman

[d-backsfan01]

1.A-Rod
2. david Wright
3. Miguel Cabrera
4. Troy Glaus
5.Hank Blalock
6. Eric Chavez
7. Morgan Ensberg
8. Chipper Jones
9. hank Blalock
10. Chad Tracy

if you disagree feel free to tell me what you disagree with or list your top 10

[Honus Wagner Rules]

1.A-Rod
2. Chipper Jones
3. Troy Glaus
4. Aramis Ramerez
5. Chad Tracy
6. Scot Rollen
7. Mike Lowell
8. Adrian Beltre
9. Joe Randa
10. Ryan Freel

Were's David Wright? Where's Hank Blalock? Adrian Beltre? Joe Randa? Ryan Freel? Does Freel even start? :o

[d-backsfan01]

Were's David Wright? Where's Hank Blalock? Adrian Beltre? Joe Randa? Ryan Freel? Does Freel even start? :o

Dang i cant beleive i forgot david wright

[SoxSon]

Ryan Freel? Does Freel even start? :o

Freel's getting inconsistent starts so far this season. He shouldn't get a spot on a top 10 list at this point.

[rockin500]

Dang i cant beleive i forgot david wright
you have beltre, but you dont have aramis ramirez? yeah, ramirez isnt doing great this year, but hes still better than beltre.

[W_Marone]

First off you have beltre but no Eric Chavez? Where Ensberg? Where's Ramirez, all imo are better than Beltre.

1.A-rod
2.David Wright
3.Miguel Cabrera
4.Eric Chavez
5.Troy Glaus
6.Scott Rolen
7.Hank Blalock
8.Morgan Ensberg
9.Chipper Jones
10.Aramis Ramirez

[JohnGelnarFan]

I think Melvin Mora is better than 8-10 of your list DBacksFan and better than Crede on Gomes List.

[Jake83]

Morgan Ensberg hit what 40+ Homers and allready has close to 20 he should be at least in the Top 5. Beltre is crap now not even Top 15 Freel is one of the worst 3rd basemen in baseball. Joe Crede is not Top 15 either.

[W_Marone]

Oops I forgot about Mora, I thought I was forgetting someone. But I still think I'll go with Crede over Mora still.

[Jake83]

Were's David Wright? Where's Hank Blalock? Adrian Beltre? Joe Randa? Ryan Freel? Does Freel even start? :o


Wags you fell to mention the Gold Glove 3rd basemen a few miles North of you.....Chavez

[W_Marone]

yes I was really surprised that Chavez wasnt on the list he's definantly a top five thirdbaseman.

[d-backsfan01]

yes I was really surprised that Chavez wasnt on the list he's definantly a top five thirdbaseman.

i forgot about him and morgan ensberg

[redban]

Miguel Cabrera...did he just slip out of everyone's mind?

[W_Marone]

yeah I forgot him too, He's still rightfield in my mind, third hasnt set in yet haha.

[Jake83]

Florida players usually slip most people's minds

[Astro]

1.A-Rod
2. david Wright
3. Miguel Cabrera
4. Troy Glaus
5.Hank Blalock
6. Eric Chavez
7. Morgan Ensberg
8. Chipper Jones
9. hank Blalock
10. Chad Tracy

if you disagree feel free to tell me what you disagree with or list your top 10
Anyone who does not list Scott Rolen in the top 5, let alone top 10, of 3rd basemen does not gain my respect... sorry

[Honus Wagner Rules]

Wags you fell to mention the Gold Glove 3rd basemen a few miles North of you.....Chavez
Yeah, him, too!

[Jake83]

1. A-Rod
2. Eric Chavez
3. Scott Rolen
4. Morgan Ensberg
5. David Wright
6. Miguel Caberea( More of a LF)
7 Troy Glaus
8 Armaris Ramirez
9 Mike Lowell
10 Bill Mueller ( At 3rd defense is just as important as hitting 30 home runs)

Notable Absences Chipper Jones(Not the same) Hank Blalock(Hits only 220 on the road) Adrian Beltre (Should be a Dodger but screw him because he is not)

[jlpennington]

1. Alex Rodriguez
2. David Wright
3. Scott Rolen
4. Miguel Cabrera
5. Morgan Ensberg
6. Eric Chavez
7. Troy Glaus
8. Hank Blalock
9. Chad Tracy
10. Melvin Mora


David Wright is one whale of a player. I love watching that guy whenever I can.


To answer the Ryan Freel question from a Reds fan: he's hardly had any starts at third this year, mostly because he played a lot of CF while Junior was on the DL. He's a better third baseman than Edwin Encarnacion, our everyday starter. There are probably only three or four guys I can think of that I'd put before Freel (to play third base) that didn't make this list, making him about 14th or 15th.

[Outta Here]

1. A-Rod
2. Eric Chavez
3. Scott Rolen
4. Morgan Ensberg
5. David Wright
6. Miguel Caberea( More of a LF)
7 Troy Glaus
8 Armaris Ramirez
9 Mike Lowell
10 Bill Mueller ( At 3rd defense is just as important as hitting 30 home runs)

WOW that is the exact same list I would hav said, spooky :eek:

Are u sure u still want Beltre the way he is playin? Ichiro will end up with more HRs than him :D

[KCGHOST]

Alex Rodriguez
Morgan Ensberg
Miguek Cabrera
David Wright
Chipper Jones
Troy Glaus
Aramis Ramirez
Melvin Mora
Scott Rolen
Eric Chavez