top non-bonds seasons of this generation

[west coast orange and black]

"which player has had the best individual season of this generation?" is easily answered: barry bonds.
of this there is no debate.

but who - not named bonds - owns the best individual san francisco giants season of this generation?

the above four, i think, are the only ones that can be considered for this question.
if there is someone who you would like to add to the poll, please jump in so that he can be added.

[west coast orange and black]

this info may be useful.

bobby bonds 1973

160 g (6)
643 ab (6)
131 r (1)
182 h (8)
34 2b (8)
4 3b
39 hr (5)
96 rbi
43 sb (4)
87 bb (7)
341 tb (1)
77 xbh (3)
148 k (1)

.283 batting
.370 obp (9)
.530 slugging (9)

player of the year
3rd league mvp voting
all-star selection
all-star mvp
gold glove award

. . . . . . . . .

will clark 1989

159 g (8)
588 ab (10)
104 r (1)
196 h (2)
38 2b (4)
9 3b (3)
23 hr (10)
111 rbi (3)
8 sb
74 bb
321 tb (2)
70 xbh (4)
103 k

.333 batting (2)
.407 obp (3)
.546 slugging (3)
.953 ops (2)

2nd in league mvp voting
nlcs mvp
all-star selection
silver slugger

. . . . . . . . .

kevin mithell 1989

154 g
543 ab
100 r (4)
158 h
34 2b (7)
6 3b
47 hr (1)
125 rbi (1)
3 sb
87 bb (5)
345 tb (1)
87 xbh (1)
115 k (10)

.291 batting (9)
.388 obp (8)
.635 slugging (1)
1.023 ops (1)

player of the year
league mvp
all-star selection
silver slugger

. . . . . . . . .

jeff kent 2000

159 g (8)
587 ab
114 r (8)
196 h (5)
41 2b (8)
7 3b (7)
33 hr (7)
125 rbi (4)
12 sb
90 rbi
107 bb
350 tb (7)
81 xbh (6)
107 k

.334 batting (6)
.424 obp (4)
.596 slugging (10)
1.021 ops (10)

league mvp
all-star selection
silver slugger

[Honus Wagner Rules]

WCOB,

Not to be nit-picky but a "generation" is roughy 13 years so only Kent's season is within "this" generation. ;)

[Edgartohof]

I'd personally go with Bonds, Kent, Mitchell, Clark

Bonds was 1 HR from a 40-40 that year, played GG caliber OF defense, he was a great force out there. He had power, could run, good defense, all you could ask for.

Then I'd go with Kent. He put up good power, .nearly a 300/.400/.600 stat line, was decent on the bases, all while at second base, and he won the MVP

Mitchell - put up a league leading 47 HR's, and led in Slg, OPS, OPS+, TB, RBI, RC, and XBH - he just powers his way past clark for me - oh, and he won the MVP

Clark - how many Win Shares did he win? 40? 44? That has to count for something. He had good power, .300/.400/.500, 100+ Runs and RBI, but wasn't that great on the bases, and the only thing he led in was TOB. Mitchell stole all of his Black ink that year. He may come in last here, but he still had a great season, and overall, is better than Mitchell.

[west coast orange and black]

wags, i based the span on the premise that a generation is the average length of time between the birth of parents and the birth of their offspring - 30 years.

1970-2005 is only 5 years added to that 30.

[west coast orange and black]

1. bonds
2. clark
3. kent
4. mitchell