PDA

View Full Version : Best Giant between Mays and Bonds?


Honus Wagner Rules
01-17-2006, 07:30 AM
Ok, Mays left the Giants in 1972. Bonds debuted with the Giants in 1993. So who was the best Giants position player between 1972-92?

The candidates:

Jack Clark
Will Clark
Bobby Bonds
Kevin Mitchell
Chili Davis
Matt Williams (although he wasn't really good until Bonds arrived)
Robbie Thompson

Jake83
01-18-2006, 01:44 AM
Best Giant for a season..... Would be Kevin Mitchell for a extended period of time May be Will Clark but he only played what 6 seasons with the Giants. Is it for a career if it is than it would be Robby Thompson

west coast orange and black
01-18-2006, 10:25 AM
best giants position player between 1972-92: will clark

best individual season:
bobby bonds 1973
will clark 1989
kevin mitchell 1989
jeff kent 2000

i gotta think about this a bit.