BBF Yankees Hall of Fame

[DoubleX]

This thread is meant to summarize the results of the BBF Yankees Hall of Fame elections. This thread is not meant for discussion.

[DoubleX]

Players Inducted (14 Total)
Yogi Berra - Catcher, 1946-1963
Bill Dickey - Catcher, 1928-1946
Joe DiMaggio - Center Field, 1936-1951
Whitey Ford - Starting Pitcher, 1950-1967
Lou Gehrig - First Base, 1923-1939
Joe Gordon - Second Base, 1938-1946
Lefty Gomez - Starting Pitcher, 1930-1942
Ron Guidry - Starting Pitcher, 1975-1988
Tony Lazzeri - Second Base, 1926-1937
Mickey Mantle - Center Field, 1951-1968
Don Mattingly - First Base, 1982-1995
Thurman Munson - Catcher, 1969-1979
Red Ruffing - Starting Pitcher, 1930-1946
Babe Ruth - Right Field, 1920-1934

Contributors Inducted (3 Total)
Mel Allen - Announcer, 1939-1964
Joe McCarthy - Manager, 1931-1946
Casey Stengel - Manager, 1949-1960

[DoubleX]

First Induction Class (7 Inducted)

Players
Yogi Berra
Joe DiMaggio
Whitey Ford
Lou Gehrig
Mickey Mantle
Babe Ruth

Contributors
Casey Stengel


Second Induction Class (5 Inducted)

Players
Bill Dickey
Lefty Gomez
Don Mattingly
Thurman Munson

Contributors
Joe McCarthy


Third Induction Class (3 Inducted)

Players
Ron Guidry
Tony Lazzeri

Contributors
Mel Allen


Fourth Induction Class (2 Inducted)

Players
Joe Gordon
Red Ruffing

Contributors
None

[DoubleX]

Results of the First Election

Total Number of Players Ballots: 13

Player Vote Total / Percentage
Yogi Berra: 12 Votes / 92.31% - INDUCTED
Joe DiMaggio: 12 Votes / 92.31% - INDUCTED
Lou Gehrig: 12 Votes / 92.31% - INDUCTED
Mickey Mantle: 12 Votes / 92.31% - INDUCTED
Babe Ruth: 12 Votes / 92.31% - INDUCTED
Whitey Ford: 10 Votes / 76.92% - INDUCTED

Bill Dickey: 5 Votes / 38.46%
Bobby Brown: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Jack Chesbro: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Nick Etten: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Lefty Gomez: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Tony Lazzeri: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Roger Maris: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Don Mattingly: 1 Vote / 7.69%
George Mogridge: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Bobby Murcer: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Paul O’Neill: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Monte Pearson: 1 Vote / 7.69%
George Pipgras: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Wally Pipp: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Buddy Rosar: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Snuffy Stirnweiss: 1 Vote / 7.69%
Mel Stottlemyre: 1 Vote / 7.69%

Total Number of Contributors Ballots: 12 (I disqualified one)

Contributor Vote Total / Percentage
Casey Stengel: 10 Votes / 83.33% - INDUCTED

Ed Barrow: 6 Votes / 50.00%
Miller Huggins: 5 Votes / 41.67%
Mel Allen: 4 Votes / 33.33%
Joe McCarthy: 3 Votes / 25.00%
Billy Martin: 2 Votes / 16.67%
Jacob Ruppert: 2 Votes / 16.67%
George Steinbrenner: 2 Votes / 16.67%
George Weiss: 2 Votes / 16.67%


Results of the Second Election

Total Number of Players Ballots: 11

Player Vote Total / Percentage
Don Mattingly: 11 Votes / 100.00% - INDUCTED
Bill Dickey: 10 Votes / 90.91% - INDUCTED
Lefty Gomez: 10 Votes / 90.91% - INDUCTED
Thurman Munson: 10 Votes / 90.91% - INDUCTED

Ron Guidry: 5 Votes / 45.46%
Graig Nettles: 5 Votes / 45.46%
Jack Chesbro: 4 Votes / 36.36%
Phil Rizzuto: 4 Votes / 36.36%
Red Ruffing: 4 Votes / 36.36%
Tony Lazzeri: 3 Votes / 27.27%
Reggie Jackson: 2 Votes / 18.18%
Paul O'Neill: 2 Votes / 18.18%
Joe Gordon: 1 Vote / 9.10%
Tommy Henrich: 1 Vote / 9.10%
Don Larsen: 1 Vote / 9.10%
Roger Maris: 1 Vote / 9.10%
Bobby Murcer: 1 Vote / 9.10%
Allie Reynolds: 1 Vote / 9.10%
Dave Winfield: 1 Vote / 9.10%

Total Number of Contributors Ballots: 11

Contributor Vote Total / Percentage
Joe McCarthy: 9 Votes / 81.82% - INDUCTED

Mel Allen: 6 Votes / 54.55%
Miller Huggins: 6 Votes / 54.55%
Ed Barrow: 5 Votes / 45.46%
George Steinbrenner: 3 Votes / 27.27%
Bob Sheppard: 2 Votes / 18.18%
Billy Martin: 1 Vote / 9.10%
Joe Torre: 1 Vote / 9.10%


Results of the Third Election

Total Number of Players Ballots: 9

Player Vote Total / Percentage
Ron Guidry: 8 Votes / 88.89% - INDUCTED
Tony Lazzeri: 7 Votes / 77.78% - INDUCTED

Elston Howard: 6 Votes / 66.67%
Jack Chesbro: 5 Votes / 55.56%
Graig Nettles: 5 Votes / 55.56%
Joe Gordon: 4 Votes / 44.44%
Red Ruffing: 4 Votes / 44.44%
Mel Stottlemyre: 4 Votes: 44.44%
Reggie Jackson: 3 Votes / 33.33%
Paul O'Neil: 3 Votes / 33.33%
Phil Rizzuto: 3 Votes / 33.33%
Goose Gossage: 2 Votes / 22.22%
Allie Reynolds: 2 Votes / 22.22%
Tommy Henrich: 1 Vote / 11.11%
Don Larsen: 1 Vote 11.11%
Bobby Murcer: 1 Vote / 11.11%
Willie Randolph: 1 Vote / 11.11%
Bobby Richardson: 1 Vote / 11.11%
Bob Turley: 1 Vote / 11.11%
Dave Winfield: 1 Vote / 11.11%

Total Number of Contributors Ballots: 9

Contributor Vote Total / Percentage
Mel Allen: 7 Votes / 77.78% - INDUCTED

Miller Huggins: 6 Votes / 66.67%
Ed Barrow: 4 Votes / 44.44%
George Steinbrenner: 4 Votes / 44.44%
Joe Torre: 2 Votes / 22.22%
Phil Rizzuto: 1 Vote / 11.11%
Jacob Ruppert: 1 Vote / 11.11%
Bob Sheppard: 1 Votes / 11.11%
George Weiss: 1 Vote / 11.11%


Results of the Fourth Election

Total Number of Players Ballots: 6

Player Vote Total / Percentage
Joe Gordon: 5 Votes / 83.33% - INDUCTED
Red Ruffing: 5 Votes / 83.33% - INDUCTED

Dave Winfield: 3 Votes / 50.00%
Elston Howard: 3 Votes / 50.00%
Jack Chesbro: 3 Votes / 50.00%
Paul O'Neill: 3 Votes / 50.00%
Reggie Jackson: 3 Votes / 50.00%
Graig Nettles: 2 Votes / 33.33%
Mel Stottlemyre: 2 Votes / 33.33%
Willie Keeler: 2 Votes / 33.33%
Bob Meusel: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Bobby Richardson: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Don Larsen: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Goose Gossage: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Herb Pennock: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Phil Rizzuto: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Roger Maris: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Tommy Henrich: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Tony Kubek: 1 Vote / 16.67%
Willie Randolph: 1 Vote / 16.67%

Total Number of Contributors Ballots: 6

Contributor Vote Total / Percentage
Ed Barrow: 4 Votes / 66.67%
George Steinbrenner: 4 Votes / 66.67%
Miller Huggins: 4 Votes / 66.67%
Jacob Ruppert: 3 Votes / 50.00%
Bob Sheppard: 2 Votes / 33.33%
Ban Johnson 1 Vote / 16.67%